
A confession: I have never seen an episode of Top Chef. It's a big demerit to my food blogger cred (such as it is), but what can I say? I don't have cable.
As such, until a few months ago I'd not heard of Mike Isabella, the chef behind Graffiato, DC's newest Italian eatery in Penn Quarter. Nor had I heard of Isabella's much-heralded pepperoni sauce. Now that I've been to Graffiato and sampled said sauce, I might have to give Comcast a call to see what else I'm missing out on.
More on the sauce in a minute. Let's talk decor. Graffiato's insides are raw. The tables are made of reclaimed wood and were built by Isabella and his father-in-law. Rafters poke out from the ceiling and are criss-crossed with pipes and cables. The brick is exposed and the light fixtures are straight out of the workshop. Sit at the bar and you'll see pizzas slide in and out of the wood-fired oven. Sit at the right table and you'll see (and hear) the chefs prepare dishes, bark orders, and carefully plate your meal. It's all about immersion. And even amidst the chaos of the kitchen, the noise of the diners, and the hard rock soundtrack, you feel welcome, like you're a part of it all.
After a round of smokey, fruity mezcal cocktails, my dining companions and I set to work on Graffiato's selection of cheeses (some local, some distant) served with a sweet, garlicky mustard jam that is absolutely sensational. Their sliced smoked and cured hams are piled on top of minature herb-and-cheese frittatas, a wry twist on the traditional ham, egg, and cheese.
Now let's talk pepperoni sauce, which I'm told was quite the hit among the Top Chef judges, and it's easy to see why. Served with crisped chicken thighs and blistered tomatoes, it's mellow, slightly sweet, and tastes exactly -- really, uncannily -- of pepperoni. Working our way through the menu of small plates and pizzas, we had oregano-crusted pork ribs slathered with a refreshing coriander yogurt, and playfully spicy meatballs served over polenta with a softly cooked egg -- solidly good plates that put interesting twists on traditional Italian comfort food. We ordered a cheddar, leek, and bacon pizza for the table which was delicious on its own, but demonstrated true worth by furnishing scraps of yeasty crust with which to scoop up the leftover sauces.
The real stars of the evening, though, were the bone marrow and the gnocchi. For the enthusiastic carnivore, having your food served to you in a hollowed-out bone is deeply satisfying. Piled into the ossified platter were soft hunks of intensely rich marrow offset texturally by crisped bacon, pistachio, and bread crumbs. A squeeze from the accompanying cured lemon brought balance to the whole affair. I methodically scraped out every last morsel and admit that it took remarkable self-restraint to keep from gnawing on the femur.
And then there's the gnocchi. One member of my dining party, betraying a propensity for the lyrical, described the little potato dumplings as having been "plucked from a cloud." Tucked in between them were soft mounds of burrata and a ragù of braised pork. Everything on the plate existed in a fragile state of semi-solidity until the moment it reached your mouth, when it all melted, disintegrated, and made us happy.
For dessert, we ordered everything. Every single item on the dessert menu. And while none of them disappointed, the gelatos were the best of the bunch. The sea salt gelato that accompanied the chocolate tart was perfectly balanced and could easily have been enjoyed on its own. The raspberry was bright and intense and a perfect partner for the chocolate gelato, which we were all convinced -- absolutely, 100-percent sure -- had some sort of smokey secret ingredient. However, a quick post-dinner chat with Chef Isabella revealed that the chocolate gelato was untouched by smoke, leaving us all confused and less confident in the sharpness of our collective palate, but too full and happy to care.
And for all we ate (and it was an obscene amount) we only touched on a small portion of the full menu. A friend in the restaurant last night described the scallop crudo special as a revelatory experience. In our gusto for Graffiato's meat and pasta offerings, we neglected the vegetable menu entirely, which was a mistake. (I can hear the blistered peppers with smoked paprika and the escarole salad with guanciale calling to me as I write.)
The good news is that this can all be rectified with a return visit. The bad news is that with all the buzz surrounding Graffiato's opening, they appear to be booked solid through the next election. I exaggerate, of course, but even if that were the case it'd be worth the wait. Hell, if a restaurant can make me reconsider selling my soul to Comcast, then waiting on line until November doesn't seem so ridiculous.